Zend certified PHP/Magento developer

Change which display is shown with “Second Screen Only” selected with multiple monitors

I have three monitors. I have two computers hooked up to these three monitors. Sometimes I need to work on one computer while having the other computer open. My display that is marked with the number two is the only display that is shown when I select the “Second screen only” option using windows key + p

Here is what my monitor setup looks like. I would like only screen one to be shown when I select show second screen only. Is there a way to change the number assigned to a display? Or have a different display number be shown when selecting the “Second screen only” option?